Shoreline Residents Spearhead Bag Ban Referendum Petition

Tom Jamieson and the Shoreline Caucus have begun a petition drive to seek repeal of Shoreline's new plastic bag ban.


A group of local residents, led by Tom Jamieson and Ginny Scantlebury, have joined forces with the bag ban activist group Save Our Choice to seek repeal of Shoreline's new plastic bag ban.

Ordinance No. 653, which regulates the distribution of plastic and paper carryout bags by Shoreline retail establishments was adopted by the Shoreline City Council on April 29, 2013. The new regulations become effective on February 1, 2014.

A referendum petition is underway, which would require the City Council to either repeal the Ordinance in its entirety or put the question to the voters in the next general election. Jamieson said that the petitioners need to get at signatures from 15 percent of the number of people who voted in the last general election by May 29, or about 6,000 signatures.

Jamieson, admits that's a tall order, since voter participation generally rises in a presidential election year. Two similar efforts by Save Our Choice, in Seattle and in Issaquah, missed the mark last year when bag bans were passed in those cities.

If the referendum petition does get enough valid signatures, the the city has two options, repeal the ordinance or put it to the voters, Jamieson said.

"I believe if they put it to the voters the voters will reject it," he said.

Shoreline is not the first Washington city to resist the regulation of retail carryout bags. “Save Our Choice was founded in December 2011 to first oppose the Seattle bag ban and bag tax,” says co-founder Craig Keller. “We are a band of volunteer citizens dedicated to fiercely defending consumer and merchant choice and to questioning the authority of utopians.”

Some Shoreline residents agree. Jamieson said, “The City has not made a compelling case. This ordinance unjustifiably restrains trade, punishes customers, provides no provable benefit to the environment, and includes no method for measuring reductions in waste or litter. Moreover, reusable bags have not been shown to be in the best interest of the health, safety and welfare of the people of the City of Shoreline.”

Ginny Scantlebury, speaking on behalf of the Shoreline Caucus, supports a repeal of the bag ban, the group said in a news release. “This ordinance goes against 3 core values that the Caucus believes in strongly: limited government, free markets, and fiscal responsibility. We don’t think that the Shoreline City Council should be involved in whether there should be plastic bags or not. They should not dictate what kind of bags the stores can offer, and they have more important issues to deal with.”

According to the Shoreline Municipal Code, a Referendum Petition must be submitted to the City within 30 days of the passage date of the ordinance. The Shoreline City Clerk has communicated a deadline of May 29 at 5:00PM for the referendum petition.

The Shoreline Referendum Petition is available for download at www.saveourchoice.us

For more information or to volunteer, please contact Tom Jamieson at 206-300-7606 or info@saveourchoice.us, or Ginny Scantlebury at info@shorelinecaucus.com. Contributions (check, no cash) may be mailed to Save Our Choice, PO Box 16716, Seattle, WA 98116.

M K Ballard May 08, 2013 at 05:26 PM
I am not familiar wtih the details of the ordinance. However, as long as it allows paper bags and does not tax the use of the paper bags I have no porblem with the ordinance. If it goes as far as the Seattle ban and puts a tax on the use of the bags, I will shop in cities that either do not have a ban or allow paper bags without an extra tax.
Jeanne Gustafson May 08, 2013 at 05:50 PM
To answer your question, it does impose a minimum 5-cent per paper bag "pass-through" fee (meaning merchants have to charge it), MK, and that 5 cents is taxable.
Brendan May 08, 2013 at 11:46 PM
Reusable bags are cheap - often times you can get them for free. I would suggest that people like MK (who claims to be unopposed to the ordinance except for that whole 5 cent bag tax) just purchase or acquire a few reusable bags and just carry on with your local shopping. How absurd of a notion is going miles out of your way to save 10-20 cents - as people who state they will take business elsewhere? People will really punish local businesses, economy and really the community by taking business elsewhere - and for what? To make a point about freedom? You can hardly make an economical argument about it. Whether you agree with this legislation or not - I would ask you this: Is it really going to be *that* big of a burden to you? Adapt. Things always change. Major metropolitan areas across the country - and around the world are doing this for the health of our planet - not to spite people or take away our freedoms. Not to mention, the argument against this ordinance is sad, weak rooted, and often funded by corporate interests that are tied to plastics manufacturing or lobbying so naturally they are going to come up with junk science or rhetoric to make you believe a bag ban is horrible... Furthermore - Patch has only covered one side of this story from the jump. Although the political and business affiliation of the op-ed writer was revealed, I'm still not impressed with the one sided coverage.
David K. Farkas May 13, 2013 at 03:43 AM
This planet will be a very different place in only 25-50 years. Our children and grandchildren may well ask, “What were you thinking? What were you doing?” Are we going to say, “Yes, there were lots of things we might have done, but we didn’t want to inconvenience anybody?” We should all get in the habit of bringing our own bags when we go shopping, as people do throughout the world. A key benefit of the plastic bag ordinance is to move people in that direction. David K. Farkas, Lake Forest Park


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »